Battle of the Euston Arch
Thursday, February 12th, 2009
Standing 70ft high and 44ft deep, supported by columns 8ft6in in diameter and carved from granite-hard Yorkshire stone, the Euston Arch should have been hard to misplace. But a deadly mix of corporate philistinism and official indifference saw one of the great monuments of London’s early railways disappear seemingly without trace - only to turn up lining the bed of an East End river.
The mystery was only solved thanks to assiduous detective work by architectural historian Dan Cruickshank - himself a long-time resident of Spitalfields. Cruickshank is a journalist, academic and broadcaster by profession, but a campaigner by instinct. Having moved into Spitalfields in the 1970s, a time when the 17th and 18th century Huguenot weavers’ houses were considered ripe for demolition and redevelopment, he immediately set about saving the buildings. As well as becoming a director of the Spitalfields Trust in 1977, he was a founder trustee in 1975 of Save Britain’s Heritage, and a committee member of the Georgian Group. The title of Cruickshank’s 1975 book, ‘The Rape of Britain’ refers to the casual vandalism visited on much of the country’s architectural heritage down the decades. And in 1993, Cruickshank took up an architectural cause that had, seemingly been lost forever more than 30 years before.
The modern Euston Station is a nondescript building, though lovers of bleakly functional 1960s architecture might leap to its defence. But the terminus is significant, being the first inter-city railway station to be built in London when it opened in 1837. The London terminus of the London and Birmingham Railway was built by the great civil engineer Robert Stephenson. These first railway termini were conceived as huge monuments to the birth of the age of steam - and of the might and prestige of the operating companies. The L&BR conceived of a fittingly grand entrance to their station. Designed by architect Philip Hardwick, the mighty Euston Arch mirrored that of Curzon Street Station, Birmingham, at the other end of the company’s mainline.
The L&BR directors described their ‘architectural embellishment’ as ‘grand but simple … well adapted to the national character of the undertaking’. Not everyone agreed: a London guide published for the Great Exhibition of 1851 described the arch as ‘gigantic and very absurd’. Undeterred, the railway company (by then the London and North Western) embellished the arch further in 1870, having ‘EUSTON’ carved onto the architrave in massive letters of gold.
By 1938, the station was in under the control of the London Midland and Scottish Railway. The LMS was not just the biggest of the British railway companies, it was the world’s largest transport group, and Britain’s biggest private company - only the Post Office employed more people. Perhaps the LMS was looking for its own monument, for the company proposed the rebuilding of Euston, and the destruction of the Euston Arch. Certainly the original Euston station was proving too cramped, and the LMS proposed an American-inspired Classical structure. The sparkling white monolith was shelved though, with war breaking out the following year.
But after the austere years of the fifties, a new spirit of modernism, and of sweeping away the old, gripped Britain. In 1960, the British Transport Commission announced its plan to demolish Euston - a new building would arise to coincide with the electrification of the West Coast mainline (which wouldn’t be completed until 1974). The station was too small and badly sited, on that everyone agreed. But did the arch have to go too? Many thought not. The London County Council advised the arch be ‘re-erected on another site in an appropriate dignified and open setting’. MP Woodrow Wyatt demanded in the Commons that the arch be saved. The Royal Fine Art Commission asked that it be consulted before demolition was ordered. Yet in an astonishing round of buck-passing, indifference and official deafness, deadlines passed as the LCC refused to act, the Minister of Transport refused to act, and eventually even Prime Minister Harold Macmillan refused to act.
Soon the arch was no more, and behind where it had stood arose the new Euston, variously described as ‘a dingy, grey, horizontal nothingness’, ‘an ugly desecration of a formerly impressive building, ‘the worst of the Central London terminuses, both ugly and unfriendly to use’ and, most succinctly ‘hideous’. Well, some people just don’t like Sixties buildings.
But there was a strange coda to the story in 1994. Dan Cruickshank used his strand of the ‘One Foot in the Past’ TV show to go hunting the lost arch. And his digging led him to Bob Cotton, a British Waterways engineer. He remembered that the stones which Frank Valori had offered to carefully store had been bought by the organisation back in 1962, and used to plug a hole in the bed of the River Lea. The cameras watched as pieces of the arch, some with the gold lettering of ‘Euston’ clearly visible, were winched from the East End river. Other pieces were then recovered from the gardens of those who had worked on the demolition.
And there the story might end, were it not for the campaigning zeal of Cruickshank, and a plan for Euston Mark 3. The historian launched the Euston Arch Trust in 1996: it has been gaining members ever since and is now headed by Michael Palin. And following the redevelopment of St Pancras, there are plans to demolish the ‘hideous’ Euston of the 1960s and build a new station, starting this year. What better to crown the new terminus than a reassembled Euston Arch? Cruickshank reckons that as much as 60 per cent of the original arch may still lie at the bottom of the River Lea. As for the rest, the Yorkshire quarry from which the original stone came is still in operation. With the developers reportedly looking for a signature structure to cap the whole development, the Euston Arch could soon be back in its rightful place.
* Read more about the campaign to rebuild the arch at http://eustonarch.org. You can also sign up to support the campaign. Those of an obsessive nature can order their own model kit of the Euston Arch (costing £5) at http://home.clara.net/rogerpattenden/eustonarch.html.
